Last edited 02 Nov 2025

HOUSING IN THE UK: Further ongoing research

• Link to mock-up of abstract Pt 1 (left) Link to mock-up of abstract Pt 2. Source: Norman Fellows

• Timeline graphic. Source: ChatGPT, edited by Norman Fellows

Contents

[edit] PREFACE

In 1995, Brenda Vale wrote:—

Given the infinite regress argument against so-called “permanent" housing built in the UK between 1918 and 1968 it seems rational to take the THP as a starting point for further ongoing research. [1]

[edit] INTRODUCTION

In her introduction, Brenda Vale wrote:—

In 'Housing in the UK', Norman Fellows identified an infinite regress in housing in the UK from Tudor Walters in 1918 to Parker Morris in 1968.

However, this follow-up article assumes:—

Thus the purpose of this follow-up article is:—

• Progress graph, Paddington. Source: Hutton Archive/Getty Images

[edit] IDENTIFYING A PROGRESSION

John Temple has argued:—

However, the so-called "permanent dwellings" he refers to were the product of a long-life dwelling philosophy and therefore part of the ongoing regress.

Thus the argument from anticipatory design proposes:—

The following items are listed here in relation to the THP:—

See checklist (right) for links to AI generated research.

• Checklist for further ongoing research. Source: Pinboards, Norman Fellows

Learn More

[edit] • TEMPORARY HOUSING PROGRAMME

• Selected images of the Arcon Mark V. Source: 1944 Arcon, Archiblog

Learn More

Notes

According to Brenda Vale:—

Learn More

For further information see 'PERIOD ONE: 1944-1949', DOMESTIKIT: UK

[edit] • SHORT LIFE HOUSING STUDY—U.K.

According to Cedric Price:—

and explained:—

  • "This work has been concerned with postulating a coarse model of a 'housing' service which would help correct the shortfalls and ensure that future appetites and demands, as yet unknown, can be identified and when necessary, satisfied."
  • To test such a coarse model of service, an equally crude manufactured component in the service has been designed and developed so that proposed service and structure can be refined and sharpened against each other in a process of constructive abrasion.
  • (ib. p.620)

• House Type A - Source: CCA

• House Type C - Source: CCA

• Axonometric - Source: CCA

• Source: Cedric Price Supplement No.4, p.630, AD 10/71

• Selected images from 'Housing Research'. Source: Cedric Price

Cedric Price also raised the following key points:—

and explained:—

  • "This interlocking and restrictive system can be broken apart at a key point by changing one of the fundamental rules of the game — the notional 'life' of the building. Such a lever only becomes valuable, however, if the pressure applied to it can produce the fundamental changes:
  1. "Ability for the individual to match desired mobility to performance.
  2. Maximum fit between desired degree of occupancy and performance. This must include both 'over' and 'under' occupation: overall normative criteria in such matters must be replaced by the individual's own criteria. Similarly, enforced and undesired 'over' and 'under' occupation must be wiped out.
  3. Maximum separation between the housing product and the land upon which it alights, enabling rapid response to greater mobility.
  4. Maximum speed of 'on-site' erection and removal of the housing unit to eliminate as far as possible the loss-making effects to the community of fallow ground caused by development. Mediaeval cultivation must cease.
  5. Maximum environmental 'plateau' for each dwelling coupled with minimum time lapse before such a plateau can be up graded by every individual through the selection of a new model. (see AD 9/71 p.569)
  6. If the likely period of occupancy of a dwelling by the same occupier cane be forecast, then it is possible to make some estimate of the frequency of major changes in the function of the dwelling, and to select the materials and equipment of the dwelling in such a way that their life will be expended at times of major functional change or that they can be re-used in a different way or a different dwelling.
  7. A model has been developed which approximates to the pattern of residential mobility existing in the UK at the present time.
  • (ib. pp. 621-622)

For further information see '1967 SHORT LIFE HOUSING STUDY—U.K.' in 'PERIOD TWO: 1965-1971', DOMESTIKIT: UK

[edit] • DOMESTIKIT

Work on Domestikit began in January 1972 with the publication of the second part of the summary by Cedric Price, namely:—

However, the title was not coined by Norman Fellows until October 1972 after a reading of a soliloquy entitled 'I Figure' published in 'Ideas and Integrities' in 1963 in which Buckminster Fuller discussed the idea of a "World-Wide Dwelling Service" (p.109).

Domestikit itself was not actually published by Norman Fellows until 10 January 1978 at a meeting with Cedric Price at 38 Alfred Place.

• Source: 3D Warehouse • Source: 3D Warehouse • Isometric projection - separations. Source: NF fonds on Flickr • Typical plans - Source: NF fonds on Flickr

• Selected digitized items from the Domestikit Catalogue — Source: Domestikit on 3D Warehouse

For further information see 'PERIOD THREE: 1972-1977', DOMESTIKIT: UK

[edit] CONCLUSION

This article concludes:—

However, there is an argument against progressive housing as exemplified by Cedric Price's short life housing and hence Domestikit.

Therefore this article also concludes:—

  • ... that further ongoing research is required.

[edit] Notes

[1] A working hypothesis was constructed by Norman Fellows In 'Housing in the UK'. It is provisionally accepted in this article as a basis for further ongoing research.


[edit] APPENDIX - AI GENERATED QUESTIONNAIRE

Note: AI can make mistakes - these questions should be checked before use.

Cedric Price has suggested:—

  • ... that, in relation to housing, there is an indeterminate situation rather than a soluble problem; and
  • ... that housing, houses, house and home may be unhooked.

[edit] • HOUSING

Learn More

[edit] • HOUSES

Learn More

• Screenshots of initial questions from 'Expediency' by Cedric Price. Source: Pinboards, Norman Fellows

  • "The second range of questions to determine such things as the (continuous or intermittent) rate of production, range of products, frequency of alteration in demand and the nature of such alteration must be related to the initial questions and not 'packaged' for the convenience of the programmers."
  • (Cedric Price, ib.)

[edit] • HOUSE

Learn More

[edit] • HOME

Learn More

• Screenshots of second range of questions from 'Expediency' by Cedric Price. Source: Pinboards, Norman Fellows

NOTE:—Glimpses of some of the implications of such questions can be obtained by clicking on the 'Learn More' links.

Further, Cedric Price asked:—

  • "Why should anyone assume that such a display of intellectually edible concepts will ever reduce, when challenged with the hunger for somewhere to LIVE?"
  • (ib.)

BACK TO TOP


[edit] Bibliography

John Temple (2022) 'A Radical and Progressive Legacy: Labour’s Housing Record, 1945 to 1951', Labour History Review, vol. 87, no. 1, Liverpool University Press

John Temple (2023) 'Slaying Squalor: An assessment of Labour's housing record, 1945 to 1951', ResearchGate

Ministry of Public Building and Works (1944) 'Demonstration Houses: A Short Account of the Demonstration Houses & Flats erected at Northnolt', HMSO

Brenda Vale (1995) 'Prefabs: A History of the UK Temporary Housing Programme', drive.google.com


[edit] Related articles on Designing Buildings

DOMESTIKIT: UK

Housing in the UK

Housing Research by Cedric Price

The Commons

Designing Buildings Anywhere

Get the Firefox add-on to access 20,000 definitions direct from any website

Find out more Accept cookies and
don't show me this again